Old Mill
C cd do xl i, Elysburg Rd, Elysburg, PA 17824, United StatesRestaurant $10 to $20
1722 Dual Hwy, Hagerstown, MD 21740, United States
Menu and hours last checked
Walking into Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant instantly sets the tone for a casual, welcoming pizza spot right on 1722 Dual Hwy in Hagerstown. The moment you step in-or even when you order for curbside pickup or no-contact delivery-you can tell comfort food is the main attraction here. From piping hot slices of classic New York-style pizza to smaller plates perfect for a quick bite, the menu is built for those who love hearty flavors without fuss. Coffee is served up alongside vegetarian-friendly options, giving a little something for everyone whether you’re here for a sit-down meal or grabbing takeout on the go. The dine-in area manages to feel cozy without being cramped, so whether you’re catching up with friends, fueling up before errands, or just indulging in a solo pizza feast, the vibe matches the menu’s approachable style. Delivery and takeout options make it easy to enjoy their offerings at home, and the no-contact service ensures everything is convenient and safe. The combination of comfort-oriented dishes and quick bites means you can savor a classic pizza pie, enjoy a small plate, or sip your coffee while deciding what to try next. Every item on the menu feels thoughtfully crafted to balance convenience with flavor, and the casual atmosphere invites repeated visits, whether for a spontaneous lunch or a relaxed dinner. Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant thrives on providing the kind of food that feels like a treat without the formality, keeping everything friendly, flavorful, and simple to enjoy.
Prices and dish names are transcribed from the restaurant's printed menu, photographed in August 2026 and reproduced on the menu page. Hours, address and service options come from the restaurant's public business profile. An editor confirmed the restaurant was trading on 4 September 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.
1722 Dual Hwy, Hagerstown, MD 21740, United States
Superb service and excellent food. Highly recommended. Their buffalo wings and pizza both are truly NY style (we lived their for a decade). Highly recommend
Wonderful thin crust pizza. Crispy. The Italian sausage was sliced, not chunks. Sliced is so much better! Most of the business appears to be take out, but they do have several tables if you want to eat in. We ate in and pizza was nice and hot. We also had an order of wings and they were also great.
I got the 2 medium 1 topping pizza special, the other pizza was gone before I can write the review! And that being said this pizza is dangerously delicious. I feel like from all the New York style pizzas in Hagerstown and originally being from there, this pizza comes closest to home! Afraid to say better than the beloved Rocky's too, didn't think it was possible. Please give this pizza a try ASAPPPPPP if you don't believe me! I asked for it to be baked well done, not burnt! It came out perfect. This is going to be my go to pizza spot.
Tell us what you ordered and what it cost. Two or three sentences about one dish is more useful to the next person than a star rating.
Nearest first, then across the Rio Grande Valley.