Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant menu

12 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 Pizza Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 1 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 2 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 3 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 4 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 5 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 6 Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant photo menu 7

***** Lunch Special All Day ***** 8 dishes

  • 2 Slices Cheese + Drink $7.99

    2 slices cheese + med drink

  • 1 Slice Cheese + Side Salad + Drink $9.99

    slice + salad + drink

  • 2 Slices + 2 Topping + Drink $9.99

    Choose 2 Topping + 1 Drink

  • 4 Wings + Fries + Drink $9.99

    Choose Flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Old Bay,Lemon Peppers , Crispy Fries

  • Any 6" Sub + Fries + Drink $10.99

    Any 6'' Sub ( Hot or Cold ) + Crispy Fries + Med Drink

  • Chicken Chipotle Panini + Fries +Drink $13.99

    Ciabatta Panini,Fresh Sauteed Chicken,chipotle sauce,lettuce,tomato,onion,bacon,ranch,provologne

  • Any 12'' Sub + Fries + Drink $15.50

    Choose Any Sub ( Hot or Cold ) Crispy Fries

  • 2 Any Sub 12'' + fries + 2 Liter Soda $28.99

    Choose Any Sub (hot or cold)

***** PIZZA SPECIAL All Day ***** 6 dishes

  • 2 Medium Pizza 1 Topping $21.99

    Choose 1 Topping Each

  • 2 Large Cheese Pizza $24.50

  • 1 Large 1 Topping Pizza + 8 Wings + 2 Liter Soda $26.49

    Flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Old Bay,Lemon Peppers, (ranch or Bleu cheese)

  • 2 Large 1 Topping Pizza $28.99

    Choose 2 Topping

  • 1 Large Cheese Pizza Any 12 '' Sub + 8 Wings $31.99

    1 Large Cheese Pizza Any 12 '' Sub + 8 Wings

  • 2 Large Cheese Pizzas + 20 Wings $45.98

    2 Large Cheese Pizza + 20 Wings

Appetizers & Sides 24 dishes

  • French fries $4.49

    Crispy Fries

  • Cheese Fries $6.99

    Crispy Fries With Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • Bacon Cheese Fries $8.50

    Crispy Fries With Bacon & Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • Pizza Fries $7.99

    Crispy Fries With Pizza Sauce & Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • Jalapeno Bacon Cheese Fries $8.50

    Crispy Fries,Dice Jalapeno,Bacon With Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • Chicken Bacon Cheese Fries $8.50

  • Crab Fries $10.99

    Crispy Fries,Crab Meat, Melted Mozzarella Cheese With Old Bay Seasoning

  • 8 Wings $9.99

    Choose Flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Old Bay,Lemon Peppers, Side (Ranch Or Bleu Cheese)

  • 10 Wings $12.50

    Choose Flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Old Bay,Lemon Pepper, Side (Ranch Or Bleu Cheese)

  • 8 Boneless Wings $8.99

    flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Lemon Pepper,Old bay

  • 12 Boneless Wings $12.50

    flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Lemon Pepper,Old Bay

  • 24 Boneless Wings $21.00

    flavor Buffalo,BBQ,Mango Habanero,Lemon Pepper,Old Bay

  • Onion Rings $4.99

    Side Ketchup Packets

  • Mozzarella Sticks $7.49

    Side Pizza Sauce

  • Breaded Mushrooms $7.99

    Breaded Mushrooms Side Ranch Dressing

  • Jalapeno Poppers (6) $7.99

    Breaded Jalapeno With Cheddar Cheese, Side Ranch Dressing

  • Garlic Bread $4.75

    Side Pizza Sauce

  • Garlic Bread with cheese $5.75

    Melted Mozzarella Cheese,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Chicken Nuggets (9) $6.75

    Serving With Ketchup Packets

  • Shrimp Basket (6) $7.75

    Serving With Cocktail Sauce

  • Chicken Tenders with Fries (3) $8.75

    Serving With Ketchup Packets

  • Chicken Tenders With Fries (5) $10.75

    Serving With Ketchups Packets

  • Pepperoni Rolls (6) $9.99

    Serving With Side Pizza Sauce

  • Cheese Bread Pizza $9.99

Salads 10 dishes

  • Small Side Salad $4.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, green peppers, carrots, banana peppers, broccoli, olives, cucumbers, croutons and cheese

  • Tossed Garden Salad $6.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, green peppers, carrot, banana peppers, broccoli, olives, cucumbers, croutons and cheese

  • Anti-pasta Salad (Large) $12.49

    Salad with ham, salami and cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion, green peppers, banana peppers, carrot, broccoli and cucumbers

  • Fresh Sauteed Chicken Salad (Large) $12.49

    Grilled marinated chicken strips with lettuce, tomato, onion, green peppers, banana peppers, carrot, broccoli, olives and cucumbers

  • Fried Chicken Salad $12.49

  • Chef Salad $12.49

    Turkey + Ham + Provolone

  • Buffalo or BBQ Chicken Salad (Large) $12.49

  • Steak Salad (Large) $12.49

  • Caesar Salad $7.50

    Parmesan cheese, croutons and caesar dressing

  • Chicken Ceasar Salad $12.49

Pizza 18 dishes

  • SM - Cheese Pizza $11.99

  • Medium - Cheese Pizza $13.00

  • Large - Cheese Pizza $14.50

  • SM-Paradise Spec Pizza $17.99

    Includes pepperoni, mushrooms, italian sausage, onions, green peppers & extra cheese

  • SM-Meat Lovers $17.99

  • SM-Hawaiian $14.99

    Ham and pineapple

  • New !!SM-Aloha Pizza $17.99

    Ham,Pineapple,Bacon,Banana peppers,

  • SM-Philly Cheese Steak Pizza $17.99

  • SM-White Pizza Garlic $14.99

  • SM-White Veggie Pizza $16.99

  • SM-Vegetarian $17.99

  • SM-Chicken/Bacon/Ranch $17.99

  • SM-Buffalo Chicken Pizza $15.99

  • SM-Barbecue Chicken Pizza $15.99

  • SM-Birria Pizza $17.99

  • SM-Al Pastor Pizza $17.99

  • Gluten Free Pizza $12.99

    12" Rice Flour Corn Starch Crust

  • Pizza By The Slice $2.99

    Each topping $.75

Stromboli & Calzone 10 dishes

  • Medium Stromboli $13.99

    Pepperoni,Mozzarella Cheese,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Large Stromboli $17.99

    Pepperoni,Mozzarella Cheese,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Medium Calzone $13.99

    Ricotta Cheese,Ham,Mozzarella Cheese,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Large Calzone $17.99

    Ricotta Cheese,Ham,Mozzarella Cheese

  • Medium Meat Lovers Stromboli $13.99

    Pepperoni,Italian Sausage,Ham,Bacon,Beef,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Large Meat Lovers Stromboli $17.99

    Pepperoni,Italian Sausage,Ham,Bacon,Beef,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Medium Steak Stromboli $13.99

    steak,Mozzarella Cheese,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Large Steak Stromboli $17.99

    Steak,Mozzarella Cheese,side Pizza Sauce

  • Medium Vegetarian Calzone $13.99

    Mushrooms,Green peppers,Onions,Black Olives,Side Pizza Sauce

  • Large Vegetarian Calzone $17.99

    Mushrooms,Green Peppers,Onions,Black olives,Side Pizza Sauce

Hot Subs 12 dishes

  • 12'' Supreme Paradise Special Cheese Steak $12.49

    Lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, grilled onions, mushrooms, green pepper and banana pepper,Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • 12'' Sub Cheese Steak Regular $11.99

    Lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, grilled onions and banana pepper,Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • 12'' Sub California Cheeseburger Sub with Fries $12.49

    2 hamburger patties served with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, grilled onions and banana peppers

  • 12'' Sub Pizza Steak $11.99

    Steak, pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

  • 12'' Sub Philly Steak $11.99

    Onions, green peppers, mushrooms,Melted Mozzarella Cheese

  • 12'' Sub Eggplant Parmigiana with Melted Mozzarella $11.99

  • 12'' Sub Veal Parmigiana with Melted Mozzarella $11.99

  • 12'' Sub Meatball Parmigiana with Melted Mozzarella $11.99

  • 12'' Sub Sausage Parmigiana with Melted Mozzarella $11.99

  • 12'' Sub Chicken Parmigiana with Melted Mozzarella $11.99

  • 12'' Sub Fresh Sauteed Grill Chicken $11.99

    Melted mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub fried Chicken Sub $11.99

    Melted Mozzarella Cheese,Lettuce,Tomato,Mayo,onions,Banana Peppers

Cold Subs 7 dishes

  • 12'' Sub Italian Special $12.49

    Ham, salami, capicola cheese,lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper,oil vinegar

  • 12'' Sub Ham and Cheese $11.99

    Lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub Salami and Cheese $11.99

    Lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub Turkey and Cheese $11.99

    Lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub Hoagie $11.99

    Ham, salami, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub Vegetarian $11.99

    Cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, onion, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers and banana pepper

  • 12'' Sub Cold Cut Special $11.99

    Ham & Turkey

Entrees 24 dishes

  • Spaghetti with Meat Sauce $14.49

  • Spaghetti with Meatball $14.49

  • Spaghetti with Mushrooms $14.49

  • Spaghetti with Sausage $14.49

  • Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce $12.99

  • Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $12.99

  • Manicotti $14.49

    3 pasta rolls stuffed with cheese, topped with house red sauce and mozzarella

  • Stuffed Shells $14.49

    3 pasta shells stuffed with cheese, topped with house red sauce and mozzarella

  • Lasagna $14.49

  • Ravioli $14.49

    Meat or cheese

  • Baked Gnocchi $14.99

    Italian potato dumplings with sauce and mozzarella

  • Gnocchi with Meat Sauce $14.49

    Italian potato dumplings with sauce

  • Homemade Baked Ziti $14.49

    Macaroni noodles mixed with house red sauce, ricotta cheese and topped with mozzarella

  • Ziti with Meat Sauce $14.49

  • Philadelphia Ziti $15.50

    Made with Philly steak, mushrooms and house red sauce

  • Baked Eggplant Parmigiana with Spaghetti $15.49

    Fried eggplant covered with house red sauce and mozzarella

  • Veal Cutlets Parmesan with Spaghetti $15.49

    with house red sauce and topped with mozzarella

  • Shrimp in a Basket $14.49

    Deep fried shrimp with a side of french fries

  • Fettuccine Alfredo $14.50

  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli $15.50

  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken $16.99

  • Chicken Parmigiana $15.49

  • Shrimp Alfredo $16.99

  • Seafood Alfredo $17.50

    Shrimp, Lobster, Ravioli

Children's Menu 4 dishes

  • Chicken Nuggets $8.50

    8 Nuggets With Fries

  • Spaghetti Meatballs Or Meat Sauce & Garlic Bread $8.50

  • Manicotti & Garlic Bread $8.50

  • Lasagna & Garlic Bread $8.50

Beverages 5 dishes

  • Large Drink $2.95

    (Coca Cola, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer,coke zero, Iced Tea, Lemonade)

  • Medium Drink $2.89

    coke,diet,sprite,coke zero,lemonade,sweet tea,root beer

  • Small Drink $2.65

    coke,diet,sprite,lemonade,coke zero,sweet tea,root beer

  • Coffee $2.50

  • 2 Liter Soda $4.25

    Coca Cola, Sprite, Fanta Orange, Ginger ale

Desserts 4 dishes

  • Cheese Cake $4.95

  • Large Chocolate Cannoli $5.75

  • Tiramisu Cup $4.95

  • Small Vanilla Cannoli $4.75

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Walking into Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant instantly sets the tone for a casual, welcoming pizza spot right on 1722 Dual Hwy in Hagerstown. The moment you step in-or even when you order for curbside pickup or no-contact delivery-you can tell comfort food is the main attraction here. From piping hot slices of classic New York-style pizza to smaller plates perfect for a quick bite, the menu is built for those who love hearty flavors without fuss. Coffee is served up alongside vegetarian-friendly options, giving a little something for everyone whether you’re here for a sit-down meal or grabbing takeout on the go. The dine-in area manages to feel cozy without being cramped, so whether you’re catching up with friends, fueling up before errands, or just indulging in a solo pizza feast, the vibe matches the menu’s approachable style. Delivery and takeout options make it easy to enjoy their offerings at home, and the no-contact service ensures everything is convenient and safe. The combination of comfort-oriented dishes and quick bites means you can savor a classic pizza pie, enjoy a small plate, or sip your coffee while deciding what to try next. Every item on the menu feels thoughtfully crafted to balance convenience with flavor, and the casual atmosphere invites repeated visits, whether for a spontaneous lunch or a relaxed dinner. Paradise Ny Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant thrives on providing the kind of food that feels like a treat without the formality, keeping everything friendly, flavorful, and simple to enjoy.

Other menus in Hagerstown

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Hagerstown listings
Call Menu Directions